Four years ago this week, I received a phone call from my mother while I was browsing in a local record store. She was calling to tell me that there had been a terrible accident, a drowning accident involving my adorable 2 year old cousin, W, and that he was being lifeflighted to Vanderbilt Children’s Hospital.
Within the hour, my sister and I were rushing from Knoxville down to Nashville, praying in a way I’ve never prayed before that when we arrived, the news would be better.
We spent most of the next 48 hours in a hospital waiting room with other assembled family members, holding vigil, holding each other, and trying to hold on to hope. Every few hours, I was able to go sit with W for a few minutes. He was on life support. His parents and grandparents, uncles, aunts and cousins held his hand and read to him and played music for him.
He passed away two days after his accident.
Since that time, I have been blessed – and I mean that in the most powerful way I can say it – to observe the grace and love and dignity with which W’s parents have lived with, accepted and grown from the experience of losing a child, everyone’s worst fear. W’s mama has also been very generous in openly sharing her journey with other grieving parents, and in doing so, she’s helped so many people.
This is my little collection of W photos. It includes photos of him, as well as photos taken of family and friends at the annual release of balloons on his birthday at the playground built in his memory.
Created with Admarket’s flickrSLiDR.
I look at these photos a lot, especially each year around this time. I especially love the one – the only one I have of all of them together – of W with all his cousins on my brother’s front porch. It was taken six years ago now, but so much has changed since that photo was taken that it seems like another time altogether. W is gone. My father and grandfather are gone. My grandmother is bedridden and dying. My brother no longer lives in that house, which had previously belonged to my parents. W’s family’s house burned down and they have a new house. I am remarried, and several new babies have joined our family (including 4 month old R, a new baby for W’s parents!). There have been surgeries and miscarriages for several family members. My eldest son has, since that photo, experienced some significant struggles and challenges, which – while I rarely discuss the matter beyond my circle of very close friends and family, because I want to preserve his privacy – have caused me the greatest pain and worry of my life thus far. But on that day, in that photo, he’s still a smiling, healthy, innocent 12 year old boy.
None of us knew what lay ahead – the good or the bad.
W’s death marked a sea change for me in how I see the world. I never clearly understood before how suddenly and permanently life could be permanently altered. I had never seen anyone close to me go through the kind of pain I watched his parents and grandparents endure. Now I have, and everything looks different.
The experience made me more grateful and yet, more wary. I see the world as more tenuous, less predictable and more raw. I look at my children now and realize that I actually have very little control over what may happen to them today, tomorrow, or three years from now. It’s a feeling of powerlessness that I’ve yet to come to terms with, because there was a time, not so many years ago, when I thought that love, combined with “good parenting” were like a talisman against everything bad in life. Well, I’m here to tell you that they aren’t.
Bad things happen to good families, to good parents, and to the children who are their world.
Life is indeed suffering. What do we do with that? How do we find joy in the midst of that suffering? How do we accept what we can’t change? How do we even KNOW which are the parts we can’t change? When do we cling for dear life and when do we let go out of love? These are some of the questions I’ve been wrestling with since W’s death, and as I’ve faced my own losses and hurts as a parent since that time.
Beautiful boy. We miss you.
5 Responses to “The end of innocence”
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.










I regularly read your cousin Julie’s blog and I admire her and her family’s courage, honesty and grace. May God bless your entire family during this painful anniversary.
Kate, this is such a moving post. I think you have verbalized the anxiety felt by most parents when we realize that love and “good parenting” are not always enough. I also think that raw, deep pain enables us to be human and reach out to others who may be experiencing pain.I think, to answer one of your questions, that we cannot let go as parents. We have to fight like hell, scratch, bite, and spend alot of time on our knees.
Katie, This is so moving and so sad. I can only begin to imagine the family pain. What a sweet child.
In your reactions, perhaps there might be a positive letting go? Life is not fair. We cannot completely control our lives or our children’s – I tried hard to hug ‘em every chance, and prepare them to be independent (but not self-centered or self-sufficient). the mystery of letting go and staying connected …
But we can be extraordinarily grateful for every day and every hug gifted to us. And we can throw our one life for one moment onto the scales on the side of life & love in the universe. That has little to do with reducing pain, but maybe living through the suffering Buddhists know.
thank you for sharing your family’s story. i try to look at my children and accept that if their deaths came suddenly they would have thoroughly enjoyed their lives and lived life to the fullest with lots of love and meaning… that it would not have been in vain. it’s painful to think about, but i think it would be even more painful to go through it without appreciating that what we’ve already had is enough – of course i want more! but i can be grateful for what we’ve already had to date.
even for those who’ve had babies stillborn, the baby they were creating leaves such a mark on their psyches, and on the bodies of the mamas… that they have indisputably changed the world and were *important* even without drawing a breath of earth’s sweet air.
I read the news on your blog that day. I spent the next days checking in for updates, praying and hoping for the best. My friends & co-workers were praying too. It has been such a long road for your family from W to R. I am glad that this year J & J are holding such a sweetheart in their arms.